Trezor driving me crazy - considering other options

Hi all -

I use a Trezor Model T with Exodus, withe bulk of my crypto (mostly BTC these days) in the Trezor and a bit directly in exodus. It works fine, but the whole setup feels clunky and I keep having this issue where I'm unable to enter the PIN code correctly.

Maybe I have fat fingers, but I even bought a little stylus and it still takes me 5 to 10 tries to get the PIN in. Sometimes I am touching directly in the center of a number using the narrow stylus and I get nothing or the wrong number. Over the years, I've seen others with similar issues but reconnecting/updates seem to help. In my case, it's gotten worse - like unusable and this morning I actually thought I might lose a pretty large amount of coin cause I just couldn't get in.

I got in. I move 6-figures of BTC into Exodus so now I have the coin on my phone in a hot software wallet.

Maybe my Trezor was just defective and I need a new one, but I thought I'd look at new options. It's sort of a confusing selection. Any thoughts on the best option? My priorities are:

1) COLD wallet, that lives in my fireproof safe.
2) Easy to use. Trezor was fine but the ui was a bit clunky
3) I am mostly holding BTC these days so thats really all I need.

I have been reading about options, but wow there are a ton of options. I could just get a new Trezor but I'm a little turned off. Any tips? I'm having trouble understanding the options.