Metamask wallet was fished and drained of ETH - What now?

Looking for some advice. I was fished about a month ago and was relieved of the small amount of ETH I had in my metamask wallet. I know exactly how it happened, and have already worked through the palm to forehead moment, so let's move on.

I do a small amount of mining with a single GPU, and I'm curious if it'd be worth trying to get my next payout to go to a brand new wallet (some confusing/unclear steps in how to do that), or pay it out to the same wallet (that it's been mining to in the meantime) and quickly transfer it after the payout? Not sure if the bot/user who fished me is still connected with the wallet, or if it's safe to say they've moved on since the last transfer? Any help would be appreciated!